Introduction
Problem Statement
The 2008 global financial crisis was
partly attributed to speculative and fraudulent financial and managerial
practices. The issues of corporate social responsibility, medium to long term sustainable
development business management and corporate governance were some of the main
focus points of the crisis. As a result, it became inevitable to explore other
financial models that could balance the economic sphere with the moral and
ethical dimensions. Islamic finance is one of these alternative models. It is a
classic that is based on an economic model that is founded on Islamic religious
values and principles. The Koran and the sunna
are the known sources of the Islamic finance model. They are the foundation of
the rules and regulations upon which the model is implemented. One of the
objectives of the Islamic sharia laws is to promote the general societal
welfare. Considering this key objective, the Islamic financial institutions design
their operations in such a way that they align their actions and decisions to
achieve social responsibility.
The Islamic financing is looked at vis a
vis socially responsible investment, which is defined as an investment that is
deemed to be socially responsible. This is mainly due to the form of business that
an organization is engaged in. Some of the underlying themes that define
socially responsible investments include avoiding investing in organizations
that sell or produce such addictive drugs as cocaine and alcohol and instead
seeking out for partnership with businesses that are keen on environmental sustainability,
clean energy, and social justice (Hussein, 2018).
Apparently, socially responsible investments can either be made in respective
companies or through exchange trade fund (ETF) or mutual fund. Incidentally,
both Islamic financing and socially responsible investment and ethics are
deemed to be mutually exclusive (Sparkes, 2007).
Definition of Key Terms
Islamic finance-
the institutionalized philosophy inspired by the Koran to guide the financial and
economic practices as well as companies and individuals on the kind of
activities they should or should not engage in and the manner in which their
projects should be funded.
Koran-
the holy book for Muslims
Socially responsible investment-
an investment that is deemed to be socially responsible
Riba-
interest. In this context of Islamic financing, it refers to earnings without
any risk involvements.
Gharar-
profits that are not based on certainty
Maysir-
effortless or easy earnings
Haram-
this refers to the act of engaging in unlawful things
Corporate social responsibility-
operating in the best interest of both the business’ stakeholders as well as the
environment and the surrounding community.
Sharia law-
instructions on how Muslims should conduct themselves and their operations.
Sunna-
the source of the sharia laws
Convergence-
the common point of meeting
Divergence-
the departure point
Religious principles-
the religious doctrines that will form the theoretical analysis of this paper
Paper Outline
Introduction
Problem
statement
Definition
of Key terms
Outline
of the proper
Main Body
Key
theories
Summary
Conclusion
Overview
of the paper
Detail
findings
Conclusion
Key
Theories
The corporate social responsibility (CSR)
follows an integral approach that involves assigning the Islamic banking
institutions explicit social objectives. This should come first before their
economic, ethical, legal, and sharia responsibilities (Hussein & Omran, Ethical Investment Revisited, 2005). Thus, as
an alternative investing and capital means, the Islamic capital market is no
doubt increasingly attracting international attention. This is mainly
attributed to the fast expansion of various products that are compliant to Islamic
sharia laws. As a result, it offers structures that are more financially efficient
and of high quality in the global market (Ghoul
& Karam, 2007). Moreover, the increased popularity of the Islamic finance
continues to attract new innovative solutions and products that being accepted
across the Islamic nations.
Over the last few decades, Islamic finance
has been an upward trajectory. Even non-Muslim countries are slowly adopting as
a safe, ethical, and remunerative alternative. It is anchored on the principles
of promoting economic activities that align to not only mainstream laws in
force but also on Islamic doctrines. It is open for both Muslims and non-Muslims.
To enable it succeed in its objectives, it is buttressed around five fundamental
pillars of Islam. It is upon these fillers that Islamic banking draw its key
theories (Ahmed, 2010). They include ban
on riba, ban on speculating and the introduction of uncertainly elements in
contracts, ban in the trade, use and investment on activities and assets that
are prohibited by the religion, the principle of profit and sharing as well as
the obligation to have real assets to underly every financial transaction.
Ban on Riba
Riba is an Arabic word that means
interest, which is prohibited in the Islamic religion. This prohibition is explicitly
based on the Koran and provides the stem upon which the Islamic economic system
in rooted. It implies that earnings must not occur in the absence of related
risks’ assumption (Asutay, 2007). Besides,
sharia laws explicitly state that earnings must be a result of man’s active
work. Therefore, the Islamic banking guarantees one an absolute proscription of
any predetermined, positive and fixed returns irrespective of the investments’
results and typology. Specifically, riba happens in the presence of an interest
rate, whether it is negative or positive. It is not only fixed ante but also connected
to the factor of time as well as the loan amount irrespective of the economic
results that are obtained from the use of the money that was given out as loan (Forte & Miglietta, 2011).
Although interest is a very crucial factor
in the operations of conventional finance, this is a concept that demands of
the Islamic finance to conduct its operations without focusing on it. Instead, Islam
advocates for the profit as a replacement of interest. Profit is considered a sharia
complaint alternative that is economically intended as the mark up or profit
rate. This implies that profits are products of investments and trade
transactions, and, hence, represent the real measure of growth that is obtained
through the use of the capital (Hassan &
Mollah, 2018). Therefore, lawful earnings are those that are accrued
from sharing of profit and loss. In Islamic finance, this is a crucial doctrine
that requires the one who holds the capital as well as he who uses it to both
share the risks and responsibility of the investments that were made.
The Ban on Gharar and Maysir
Profits that are based on uncertainty are
explicitly banned by the Koran. The gharar ban is mainly concerned with
purposes and characteristics of the instruments of the Islamic finance. To ensure
that the order remains valid, it is strictly prohibited that contracts contain uncertainty
elements in relation to the contract’s essential elements (Crane & Matten, 2010). Examples of these
include the uncertainty pertaining to the nature and purpose of the contract as
well as the price of goods that are to be bought. Therefore, the sharia laws
ban transactions that are oriented towards enrichment by chance as well as
those with elements of speculation. Enrichment by chance include participating
in such activities as placing bets and gambling while speculative elements
include hedging transactions like swaps and derivative financial elements.
This theory involves the preference of the
Islamic banking to function via the exchange contracts performance. This is
mainly aimed at ensuring that the contract performance’s deferral by any of the
parties is prevented from generating its own benefits (Hassan, 2017). Besides, the other party is also prevented from
acquiring benefits that are not proportionate to the efforts put across, which
results in price or quality variations of the asset that is on transaction in
the period between the performance and conclusion of the contract. Maysir refers
to speculation and it equally prohibits the contract’s validity. In Arabic it
means easy or easiness as well as earning effortlessly (Maghrebi, Mirakhor, & Iqbal, 2016). It prohibits one from
assuming unnecessary risks, which are characterized by excessive results. It also
denotes one’s attempt to try to acquire wealth through chance through placing a
bet on an event’s future result. Compared to the gharar, the maysir’s prohibition
value is more behavior oriented on an individual and the associated
consequences on the society.
The Concept of Haram
The Islamic religion explicitly specifies
that an individual’s behavior has social, economic, and political ramifications
not only on himself or herself but on others, clothing, and food as well. It therefore
calls on people to relate with others with honesty, good faith, cooperation,
respect, and solidarity (Kamso & Ng, 2013).
In public places, Muslims are called upon to put on respectful clothing. When it
comes to food, the religion requires its adherents to keep off from such foods
as pork meat and wine (Franzoni & Allali,
2018). These regulations provide and specifies the classifications and
definitions of several activities and actions that are considered prohibited
and admissible. These prohibitions happen under the sharia concept of haram,
which loosely means unlawful.
Therefore, the consumption or use and
trading either directly or indirectly in come activities or goods are prohibited.
For instance, Muslims are prohibited from breeding, processing and eating pork
and foodstuffs extracted from pigs, producing, selling and consuming alcoholic
drinks, selling or smoking tobacco, placing bets and gambling, trading in weapons,
and watching or acting pornography (Gilani,
2015). It can therefore be deduced from the theory that the sharia laws prohibit
the Islamic financial institutions from investing in share of either listed or non-listed
organizations that are directly or indirectly involved in the production and
trading in the goods that have been mentioned above.
The Sharing of Risks and
Earnings
The compensate for its ban on riba, the
economic system of Islam offers the sharing or profits and losses. This is
mainly aimed at ensuring that the parties are safeguarded of a transaction to take
care of their responsibilities during both periods of success and failure (Schoon, 2016). Apparently, the parties of a transaction
include both the holder and the user of the capital. Therefore, the person who
provides capital will generate returns that are proportionate to an investment’s
effective goodness without making it a pre-fixed amount. This represent the
main difference between Islamic and Western banks. The Islamic banks replace interests
with sharing of profits.
The Real Economic
Activities
Apart from banning riba, gharar, and maysir
as well as the adoption of the profit and loss sharing principles, which are
mandatory Islamic economic and financial systems, the religion also offer an
intrinsic definition of the characteristics of the such activities that can be
subject to financial transactions and investments (Oxford Business Group, 2016). As a result, all financial
transactions must be as a result of underpinning activities that are real, and
not just a mere selling and buying of monetary debts or exchange of money. On
the contrary, it is in the derivatives and swaps that are characterized by such
actions. The theoretical analysis of such Islamic banking principles above that
advocates for the ban of riba is closely linked to financial and monetary
activity (Gilani, 2015). On the other
hand, the remaining four theoretical principles are concerned with the economy,
investments and the social responsibility behavior that companies should adapt
for their businesses.
Islamic Finance’
Corporate Social Responsibility
As an economic model, the Islamic finance
is based on such values that are directed at developing the necessary
conditions for social balance. This is achieved through distributing wealth fairly.
Hence, Islamic banking is an economic concept that is aimed at achieving social
responsibility (Elmelki, 2009). This idea
has inspired many scholars to relook at the tenets of corporate social responsibility
as a whole to ascertain if it is the desired business management approach that
could cure the medium and long-term sustainability challenges faced by many organizations.
As a consequence, some scholars have
relooked at the definitions and objectives of SCR with particular reference to
how conventional financial institutions conduct their affairs. According to Gilani (2015), corporate social responsibility
is a community resource tool used by the people and the economy to not only
maximize profits for the company and its owners but also the societal benefits
as well. The theories outlined above by Franzoni
& Allali (2018) stipulates that corporate social responsibility demands
of companies to take all aspects of their operations into consideration but without
forgetting the guidelines provided by the Islamic religious principles (Maghrebi, Mirakhor, & Iqbal, 2016). This means
that as the company strives to meet the needs of the consumers, shareholders,
the employees, the environment, and the community as part of its CSR
obligations, it must not forget the important role played by the sharia laws in
aligning these obligations to the religious contexts for the general societal
benefits (Wilson, 1997). As such, a financial
institution must not exist only to operate by the prevailing laws but must go
ahead and seek to pursue what is specified in the Koran.
According to Elmelki (2009), CSR should take the form of a pyramid, which
places economic responsibility at the base of the organization’s mandate. This is
followed by the legal, ethical, and discretionary and philanthropic responsibilities
in that order. However, in the opinion of Oxford
Business Group (2016), the key considerations of CSR include the
environmental, social, philanthropic, stakeholders, and economic dimensions. On
his part, Wilson (1997), argues that CSR
should take a center stage as a fundamental part of corporate responsibility in
order to ensure that its objectives are focused on the interests of the
stakeholders. Apparently, these interests should be independent among the other
so as to be able to create value for all people involved, and by so doing, the
community benefits as well.
The context of Islamic banking is also
ripe with several studies. Most of these studies have been mainly focused on analyzing
the Islamic religion’s principles, the determinants, the disclosure, and the objectives
with the intention of highlighting the specific religious core of the social
responsibility concept in defining and dictating the Islamic Finance operations (Ghoul & Karam, 2007). Recent studies
focused on CSR that the Islamic financial institutions practice have mainly
emphasized on the CSR related perceptions as well as its doctrines with regards
to outcome measurements and practicality.
The social responsibility practiced by the
Islamic banking institutions has also attracted the interests of the International
Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Finance Institutions (AAOIFI).
In the year 2010, the institution developed its own governance standards on CSR
to give it a legal backing. Specifically, it is the Standard No. 7, which is
titled the Corporate social
responsibility conduct and disclosure for Islamic financial institutions (Asutay,
2007). According to this standard, CSR refers to all the activities that
the Islamic Financial Institutions practice for purposes of fulfilling its ethical,
economic, discretionary, and ethical responsibilities as financial linkages for
both institution and individuals.
Further to the AAOIFI definition, Standard
No.7 carries a detailed explanation of what each of the responsibilities that
form part of the CSR entail. For instance, religious responsibility is IFI’s overarching
obligation that ensures that it abides by the Islamic laws in all its operations
and dealings (Hunt-Ahmed, 2013). Economic
responsibility is the obligation that the Islamic banks have to remain
financially profitable, efficient, and viable. Meanwhile, the legal
responsibility is the IFIs’ obligation to obey and respect the regulations and
laws in the country upon which the business operates in. Ethical responsibility
is the obligation that IFIs have to respect of the customary, societal, and
religious norms that are not included as part of the conventional laws (Caddesi, 2014). Finally, the discretionary
responsibility is the expectation that shareholders have towards the IFSs that
they will perform their social role in the implementation of the Islamic ideals
alongside the economic, ethical, religious, and legal responsibilities espoused
above.
Conclusion
This paper has explored the founding
principles that qualify the Islamic financial system to be a model that is
socially responsible. It has analyzed the Islamic religious principles that act
as the founding tenets upon which the theories are based. Keeping in mind the
main objective of the proposal of establishing the manner in which Islamic
finance can be an alternative socially responsible and ethical investing, the
paper has explored most of the features of the Islamic finance institutions
that qualify it to be an option to the mainstream socially responsible and
ethical investing. To effectively achieve this, the paper has identified four
key elements that act as points of convergence between the two. These include
economic responsibility, discretionary responsibility, ethical responsibility, and
legal responsibility. However, the CSR obligation for Islamic financial institution
to assume a religious nature responsibility is the only divergent element. This
means that it is demanded of the Islamic financial institutions to respect the
obligations and the principles that the Islamic religion has established and
applied.
The Islamic financial institutions have
ethical credentials that attract both Muslims and non-Muslims to them. Besides,
a growing number of consumers who are ethically conscious and are interested in
financial systems that are socially just are also finding the Islamic banking
suitable for them. As a result, many banks are today capitalizing on the Islamic
banking’s ethical qualifications to embrace their principles and provide Islamic
financial products to both Muslims and non-Muslims. They are mainly interested
in seeking alternatives to conventional financial systems that are ridden with
riba.
As a result, the Islamic banking system
comes out as a concept that is comparable to such appealing themes as socially
responsible investments. This is mainly based on the shared core values such as
the promotion of societal and human welfare, concern for social and economic
justice, individual responsibility, protection of the environment, upholding the
responsibility to avoid unproductive and harmful activities as well as commitment
to social interest. Islamic banking is hence touted as a paradigm that is not only
socially responsible but also rooted on the Islamic religious principles.
Islamic banking is embedded on equality, ethics,
and fairness principles that are aimed at attaining the societal social well
being. It seeks economic prosperity and social justice for everyone in the
society and at the same time encourages the attainment of economic empowerment
that is sustainable. Both the Islamic finance and socially responsible
investing are guided by the moral and ethical codes. However, draws most of its
principles from the Islamic religion. Islamic finance is capable of broadening
the portfolio of the investor by linking its core values that overlap with the socially
responsible investing to access huge full ethical and social implications of
banking as well as the funds that is at the disposal of the global market. This
momentum is sometimes being developed towards the realization of the linkages
between Islamic funds with international socially responsible investment.
The theoretical studies of the Islamic religious
banking principles and its CSR concepts indicate that there is a strict
convergence between the social responsibility of financial institutions and social
responsibility in mainstream economic systems from the standpoint of Islamic religion.
This convergence is manifested through the responsibilities that that organizations
are involved in such as the managerial conduct that is obligated to protecting
the environment and shareholders as well as the creation of an economically
sustainable value through efficiently and effectively managing economic
activities. Incidentally, all these activities play a significant role towards
the attainment of sustainable development and justice to the environment and
the community in which the business operates in.
The first convergence element is found in
the economic responsibility level. This makes reference on the exact objectives
that characterize the mainstream business organizations and Islamic banking institutions.
When it comes to conventional outlook, the objective of the organization is to
create profits and value whereas the Islamic financial institutions’ objectives
are to manage their activities in an effective and efficient manner, which is
significant for profit making. This means that at this level both the mainstream
and Islamic CSRs share the same objective of making profits. This way, they are
also able to create value addition to their own companies.
In the second convergence element, the CSR
concept element together with that of protecting the interest of stakeholders
meet at the level of discretional responsibility as spelt out in the Standard
No. 7 of AAOIFI that provides an organization with the responsibility of meeting
the stakeholders’ expectations even as it respects the ideals of the Islamic religion.
In essence, it also plays a social role. The third convergence element is the
social responsibility concept. It is close to the mainstream environment responsibility
idea or assuming responsibility for economic activity’s impacts on the environment
and the natural systems.
The fourth convergence element is the
legal responsibility assumption. This highlights the basic responsibilities
that are shared by all organizations that operate within a given country. It calls
on the business organizations to respect the laws and regulations of that
country. These include rules on environmental impacts, regulations on worker
safety, and legal activities governing industries. However, the only divergent
element from the concepts of the conventional CSR is the requirement and
obligation of the Islamic banking institutions to assume a religious nature
responsibility. This include respecting the obligations and principles that the
religion of Islam has established and applying them in one’s business operations.
In conclusion, out of the five convergence
elements that exist between the mainstream and Islamic institutions CSRs that
were under investigations, four are deemed to be shared. However, the
non-convergent element refers to the Islamic banking nature itself. This means
that the fact that it is a finance system that deviate in terms of religion
makes it to impact on the methods of management and the business activities’ purpose.
These include all the business organizations and the justice and social roles
that are associated with the goals that they are supposed to accomplish. This way,
it is safe to conclude that the religious grounding of the Islamic banking’s
CSR initiatives helps it enhance its business operations and conducts itself
ethically.
