Kincaid's
"Girl
The Girl, is a 1978 New Yorker published short story that entails an advice that a
mother delivers to her daughter but the daughter interrupts on two occasions to
either defend herself or ask a question. The mother is using the advice to achieve
two ends of scolding and encouraging her daughter. The author, Kincaid separates
the wise words and the admonishments using semicolons although there are a lot of
repetitions particularly when it comes to issuing a warning against turning
into a slut. Nonetheless, apart from such repetitions, there is no forward chronology
in the short story (Kincaid 1). Girl does
not have a beginning, a stem or a conclusion.
The story has only two characters-the
mother and the daughter. The mother happens to be the main speaker of the text.
She dispenses prolonged pieces of advice and nuggets of wisdom to her only
daughter and instill in her values on the most appropriate ways of running a
household and live a respectful life. But in between her wide words, she throws
in some scolds at her daughter out of the fear that she might pursue prostitution.
However, this does not take away the deep caring that she demonstrates towards
her daughter. On her part, the daughter is in her preadolescent years and
keenly listens to her mother’s advice. She does not say much and only speaks
when she defends herself against the accusations form her mother that she might
choose a promiscuous life. The little protests put forth by the girl indicates
some resentment although the author desist from offering her deep feelings and
thoughts.
Girl is rich in symbolism. The benna or Antiguan folksongs have been
used to signify the dreaded subject of sexuality. The mother is worried that
her daughter knows too much for her age. Benna were historical songs by the
native Antiguan to disseminate scandalous gossip and rumors albeit secretly. Therefore,
singing benna in Sunday school, is an obvious portrayal of disrespect.
The main themes of the short story include
the danger of female sexuality and the transformative power of domesticity. The
mother is worried that her daughter’s current behaviors will lead her to promiscuity
if not changed. The respectability or reputation of a woman determine the kind
of life she will lead. Therefore, it is imperative to conceal and fiercely guard
sexuality to maintain that respect. The mother hence takes her daughter through
several actions that are considered taboos in the community like squeezing a
loaf of bread when one wants to purchase it. This is symbolically used to warn
the daughter of the dangers of engaging in premarital sex.
The mother is also a strong believer in
domestic knowledge. She considers domesticity as a platform through which her
daughter would be saved from ruin and promiscuity as well as preparing her to
be a more productive and respectful member of the society. According to her, a
woman is either respectful or a slut. Domesticity is best achieved through
household tasks that also bring prestige and power to the women in addition to
keeping them busy hence protecting them from falling into temptations. But for
the mother, it goes beyond that and also ensures that a woman’s respectability
is assured.
Kingston's
"No Name Woman
The No Name Woman story by Maxine Hong Kingston
aptly depicts the manner in which gender in the Chinese society dictates the
entire existence of the human race. Women are supposed to play second fiddle to
men and even take orders from them. This is a feminist book that the author
uses as a platform to figure out what it means to her to be an American woman
of Chinese descent. She does this by considering the stories of some great
women whom she considers influential to her. These include her aunt who is
nameless, the Brave Orchid, her mother, another aunt called Moon Orchid, and Fa
Mu Lan, the warrior. This story is indeed coming of age and portrays the
memoirs of being a girl (Kingston 1). It tackles
several girlhood related issues such as motherhood, sisterhood, wifehood, patriarchy,
daughterhood, and child bearing.
The main character of the story is Maxine.
She comes out as an intellectual but shy, introspective and awkward. Her childhood
was characterized by anguish where she had to confront two competing cultures,
the Chinese and the American. The no name woman is Maxine’s aunt. She plays a
central role in driving the theme of the narrative as she drowned herself
together with the baby after being accused by her Chinese villagers of
infidelity with a man, who in real sense coerced her into it. The family
considers the woman’s actions unforgivable and christen her No Name Woman (Kingston 3). However, the author dedicated an
entire chapter to her in the book.
Maxine’s mother is called Brave Orchid to
denote her resilience, resourcefulness, and bravery. This is even demonstrated
by her decision to attend a medical school, one of the toughest subjects
traditionally reserved for men. Her demeanor is exactly the opposite that of
her sister, Moon Orchid, who is described as a passive, delicate and elegant woman.
These attributes work against her when she is rejected by her husband. She is overwhelmed
by the event and end up in a mental institution. Maxine’s father, Tom Kingstone
was the first member of the family to come to America. Unlike many Chinese men,
he chooses to uplift and support his wife by bringing her to the U.S to further
her career. These are the qualities of a man who believe in the power of women and
has no issues with women empowerment.
Other characters include Fa Mu Lan, Ts’ai
Yen, and the Silent Girl. Fa Mu Lan is best known for her legendary literary
acumen in novels, operas, and ballads. She inspired Maxine a lot. Ts’ai Yen was
a prolific poet who was enslaved for twelve years while the Silent Girl was the
victim of Maxine’s oppression while in the sixth grade because of her non-conformity
and unpopularity. All these characters have various roles in driving the author’s
message. They are either too timid and unstable or very strong and asserting.
The central theme in story is feminism. Throughout
the five chapters of the book, Kingston is devoted to giving voiceless women a
voice and platform to express themselves. In the story of the No Name Woman, which
forms the first chapter of the book, Kingston breaks the silence that family
has imposed on the aunt for her supposed extramarital affair. The aunt declines
to provide the name of the man who fathered her child to the chagrin of the family
and the villagers. Although a nameless woman should be someone without a voice
or a story worth telling, the author refuses to silence her and dedicates a whole
chapter to her to give her a voice.











































